Cookie Exchange Thursday, December 17th ($15.00 Reservation Fee)

Dorothy Ann Bakery will be celebrating its 13th annual Cookie Exchange and like everything else in 2020, it will look a little bit different.  The safety of our customers and employees remain our top priority, therefore, we have made some modifications to this event to ensure public health and safety measures are upheld while preserving the intent of the Cookie Exchange experience.

This year will be focused on the shopping experience rather than the social gathering you have come to love, with thirty-minute time slots reserved for each shopping block.  To ensure the highest safety standards, we have transformed our store into a Holiday Market filled with DAB’s most popular products at a special holiday price (everything in-store will be 10% OFF during the cookie exchange!!).  These products include, but are not limited to: cupcakes, candy, decorated cookies, fruitcake, yule logs, pies, and MUCH MORE!!! Displays will be 6 feet apart to allow for proper social distancing.

We believe that a “Tradition of Great Taste” begins with a first bite – therefore, in place of our annual “Holiday Sample Room,” all customers participating this year will also receive a “Take-Home Sampler” of DAB Holiday Specialties for FREE!!! 

As for the cookies, during the online registration, customers will select between three different pre-packaged cookie boxes (options listed below).  During the event, you will still have the option to purchase additional cookies at a discounted price.

"Santa's Favorite"  Cookie Box includes: 12 Christmas cut outs, 12 Russian tea cakes, 6 Turtles, 6 Red spritz, 6 Blueberry flips, 6 Almond spritz, 6 Green spritz, 6 Candy cane thumbprints, 6 Chocolate dipped spritz, 6 Swedish dreams,  6 Rainbow spritz, 6 Holiday pretzels, 6 Mint green holly, and 6 Chocolate dipped sticks. This option will be packaged in 1 white window box, gift wrapped with holiday bow.
    $47.99 (8 dozen cookies total)

"Mr. & Mrs. Claus" Cookie Box includes: 4 of each: Ginger snaps, Holiday pretzels, Chocolate dipped spritz, Christmas tree cut outs, Santa cut outs, Raspberry pecan thumbprints, Turtles, Almond spritz, Cherry cordials, Blueberry flips, Chocolate thumbprints, Red spritz, Green spritz, Swedish dreams, Cinnamon crisps, Star cut outs, Bell cut outs, Candy cane thumbprints, Rainbow spritz, and Chocolate dipped sticks.  This option will be packaged in 2 white window boxes, and both boxes will be tied together with a holiday bow.
    $47.99 (80 cookies total)

"Rudolph's Favorite" Cookie Box includes: 12 Russian tea cakes, 6 Green spritz, 6 Chocolate thumbprints, 6 Red spritz, 6 Candy cane thumbprints, and 12 Christmas cut outs. This option will be packaged in 1 kraft colored box, gift wrapped with holiday bow. 
     $26.99 (4 dozen cookies total)



Reservations must be made ahead of time

Sign-up online at (

All reservations are limited to ONE guest (sorry – no children allowed)

$15.00 Reservation Fee (non-refundable), this deposit goes toward your purchase

Splitting boxes will not be permitted inside the store

In-store dining and seating will not be available

Cookie sampling will not be available

Special requests for curbside pickup will be honored 


Please select your time slot and your cookie box selection in the drop down menu below.

If you would like to purchase more than one box, return back to this page and please be sure to select the same time slot!

At the check out calendar, select date of Cookie Exchange and latest time available for pick up. 



For Store Pick up only

Store Hours
Mon - Closed

Tue thru Sat: 7:30-4pm

Sunday 7:30 - 12pm