After viewing the online store, if you are unable to find a style/design you are looking for, please fill out our
and our Decorating Team will get back to you within 48 hours to discuss options and availability!
Store Hours:
CLOSED EVERY MONDAY
Tues.-Friday 7:00am-5:00pm,
Sat 7:30am-4pm, Sun 7:30am-12pm
Our handcrafted pies are created by our talented baking staff at Dorothy Ann Bakery.
We make pie crust, fillings, and toppings here at the bakery to ensure the highest quality ingredients are used with no added preservatives. These time honored recipes passed down from generations are the perfect shareable treat to celebrate any occasion.
*Pie orders require 72 hours notice*
$18.99
Sliced Apples and a touch of cinnamon covered in our flakey homemade pastry crust. Serves...
$20.99
Maine wild Bluberries are the star of this Pie! Gorgeous with the handmade lattice crust!...
$18.99
Fresh sliced bananas and creamy homemade custard fills our flakey pie crust. We top it...
$18.99
Sweet flake coconut blended in our homemade custard filled in our flaky crust topped with...
$20.99
No wonder George Washington chopped it down - these cherries are to chop for...Best cherry...
$21.99
This pie's unique chocolate cake crust makes it extra light and chocolaty. Add a smooth...
$12.99
Don't need an entire pie? Try a 1/2 pie!! Serves 4.
$18.99
Sliced apples with a touch of cinnamon in our flakey pastry crust topped with dutch...
$20.99
Fresh tart lemon and lemon cream in our pastry crust topped with real whipped cream...
$24.99
NO gluten added 7" white cake filled with a creamy custard and fudge frosted, swirled...
$39.99
Sliced Apples and a touch of cinnamon covered in our flakey homemade pastry crust. 1/4...
$20.99
Fresh Florida Key Lime juice is the star ingredient of this pie. A buttery graham...